Jen Schefft/Facebook
Jen Schefft got engaged to Season 3 The Bachelor star Andrew Firestone in 2003 but they called off their engagement after several months.
After also briefly dating original The Apprentice winner Bill Rancic, Jen went on to star in the third season of The Bachelorette, but she ended up rejecting -- in a move that proceeded the controversial decisions of later The Bachelor stars Brad Womack and Jason Mesnick -- both John Paul Merritt and her selected suitor Jerry Ferris.
Jen went on to marry businessman Joe Waterman in May 2009 and they have two beautiful children together, daughters Mae and Charlotte.
Jen and Joe met on a blind date when they each lived in Chicago.
After initially raising their family in Chicago the couple now lives in northeast Ohio, where Jen is originally from.
